Tails and Ethics: The Controversy of Tail Docking of Boxer Dogs
The issue of tail docking and dew claw removal has sparked significant debate and disagreement. We’ve received some negative comments on our tail docking YouTube videos. From these comments we’ve learned that some people are deeply passionate about these issues and they won’t hesitate to express their views. We understand the controversy surrounding these choices revolves around questions of pain, necessity, tradition, and evolving perspectives. Although, we won’t address dew claws specifically in this discussion; it’s closely related to the issue of tail docking. Today, we will delve into our kenne'l’s approach to addressing the common controversies surrounding these procedures.
Dream our oldest female Boxer
Ethical Dilemmas
The Age-Old Debate: Tail docking in Boxer puppies is often performed when they are just a few days old, raising ethical concerns about the pain and distress inflicted without the puppies’ consent.
Our response: We prioritize the well-being of our litters, and we’re attentive to pain management during their tail docking. In our experience, when we apply the initial band to dock the tail, we hear a yelp or squeal from the puppy. However, we have not observed additional signs of distress or whimpering from the puppies afterward.
We treat our puppies as part of our family, and we understand that people may draw tail docking comparisons to other practices, such as human ear piercing. We had our daughters’ ears pierced when they were toddlers, and each of them cried for less than a minute. Today, they enjoy wearing earrings and have no recollection of the piercing experience.
We acknowledge that people may also have opposing opinions about ear piercing, but we believe that at the end of the day, our commitment to the well-being and happiness of both the human and canine members of our family remains unwavering.
A Cosmetic Choice with No Medical Merit
Lack of Medical Justification: Tail docking in Boxer dogs is typically done for cosmetic reasons, adhering to breed standards. However, there is no medical necessity for this procedure, as tails serve an essential function in canine communication and balance.
Our response: In our observation of dogs with docked tails in various breeds, including Boxers, shows that they are capable of running, playing, and engaging in various activities without balance problems. Their body structure naturally compensates for the shorter tail.
While tails do play a role in canine communication and balance, dogs have developed other means of communication and adaptation to maintain balance. These can include body language, ear position, and shifting their weight. We have not observed any issues with the balance of dogs or from our litters.
Dream’s Litter #3 sleeping
Health Risks and Complications
Unwanted Outcomes: Tail docking can lead to complications such as infection, excessive bleeding, and improper healing, raising concerns about the well-being of the puppies.
Our response: We closely monitor the puppies post-tail banding, regularly checking for any signs of tail growth or potential infections. We maintain a clean environment by regularly cleaning their whelping mats and ensuring the hygiene of both the puppies’ tails and the tail banding instruments. This diligent care is crucial for a successful and healthy outcome.
Evolving Breed Standards
Breed Standards and Identity: According to American Kennel Club (AKC) guidelines for competition, the tail of the Boxer should be docked and if it isn’t it should be severely penalized. Research from the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) indicates justification for docking working dogs’ tails lack substantial scientific support. While some breed standards have shifted to discourage or disallow tail docking, leading to inconsistencies in breed appearances and identity.
Legal Restrictions: Many countries and regions have banned or restricted tail docking for non-medical reasons, making it a legal and ethical consideration for breeders like us. The U.S. does not have this restriction.
Public Sentiment: The growing opposition to tail docking among the public reflects changing perspectives on what is considered humane and ethical.
Our response: At our kennel, we follow the laws and regulations for our business. We also respect and consider the preferences of our customers when it comes to the look of our boxers. We are committed to maintaining the highest standard of care and welfare of our puppies, ensuring their well being and health at the beginning of their lives until they go to their forever homes.
In Conclusion
Our goal is to continue engaging in respectful dialogue and education about this matter, adapting to evolving perspectives, laws and regulations, but while always prioritizing the best interests of our canine companions.
Wiggles and Giggles ~ Joke of the Week
Q: What do you get when you cross a dog and a phone?
A: A golden receiver!
Subscribe to YouTube channel @dreamOnkennels. Below you can check out the tail docking process.